Presa libera si Palestina

Dupa discutiile aprinse cu Carbonaru depre Wikileaks in particular, si libertatea presei in general, mi s-a sugerat ca parerea mea despre prezentarea situatiei din Palestina in presa este eronata. Parerea mea era ca presa sustine aproape exclusiv Israelul in acest conflict de interese, sa-i zicem.

Asa ca, o sa fac un mic studiu aflat la indemana oricui (nu afirm ca e stiintific dar e mai bun decat nimic). Sa incepem:

Metodologie:

Caut pe Google "Gaza blockade exports" si voi analiza rezultatele de pe prima pagina. O sa ma axez doar pe sursa articolului, titlul articolului si primele paragrafe cel mult, adica fix bucata pe care toti care ajung la articol o citesc.

Rezultate:

243000 rezultate


1. YNetNews (Israel) 9 dec 2010
France welcomes Gaza blockade easements
"France announced it welcomes Israel's decision to boost exports from the Gaza Strip but called on the Netanyahu administration to ease conditions further."
2. BBC (Marea Britanie) 8 dec 2010
Gaza blockade: Israel eases export restrictions
"Israel says it will allow more exports out of Gaza, further easing its blockade of the Palestinian territory."
3.Yahoo (S.U.A.) 8 dec 2010
Israel eases blockade, approves more Gaza exports
"Israel decided Wednesday to allow increased exports from the Gaza Strip, further easing its blockade of the territory run by the militant Palestinian Hamas group."
4. Daily Star (Liban) 9 dec 2010
Israel relaxes Gaza blockade, permitting limited exports
Israel announced a further relaxation of its blockade of the Gaza Strip Wednesday, saying exports of manufactured goods would now be permitted in a move that major powers welcomed as significant.
5. Care2com link la articolul de la BBC
6.Arab News (Arabia Saudita) 8 dec 2010
Gaza blockade eased to export more goods
"Israel on Wednesday announced a further relaxation of its blockade of the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip, saying exports of manufactured goods would now be permitted in a move that major powers welcomed as significant."
7. Global Research (Canada) 24 iun 2010
Israeli Gaza Blockade Announcement Silent on Issue of Gazan Exports
"Montreal - On late Sunday, June 20, Israeli spokesman Mark Regev announced "...a green light of approval for all goods to enter Gaza except for military items and materials that can strengthen Hamas's military machine." "
8. RTT News (S.U.A) 8 dec 2010
Israel Eases Gaza Blockade Further, Allows Exports
"Israel has decided to allow more concessions in its blockade of the Gaza Strip, which had crippled life in the militants-ruled coastal territory for four years."
9. The Telegraph (Marea Britanie) 9 dec 2010
Israel eases Gaza blockade
"Israel has decided to allow increased exports from the Gaza Strip, further easing its blockade of the territory run by the militant Palestinian Hamas group."
10. Amnesty International 18 iul 2010
Gaza: Blockade 'Easing' not enough, say leading NGOs, as EU's Baroness Ashton visits
"The EU must insist on the full lifting of the blockade of Gaza, not just its easing, if it is serious about helping the economy of Gaza recover and allowing its people to rebuild their lives, says a group of 18 international development, human rights and peace-building organisations, as EU High Representative Catherine Ashton visits Gaza today (18 July)."
11. Haaretz (Israel) 16 iun 2010
Ashton: Israel must allow Gaza to resume exports
"EU's FM visits Gaza Strip; Minister Edelstein: I hope that Ashton will understand there is no humanitarian crisis in Gaza."

Analiza:
Ca localizare a rezultatelor avem: 2 Israel, 2 Marea Britanie, 2 S.U.A., 1 Liban, 1 Arabia Saudita, 1 Canada. Ce imi sare in ochi e lipsa rezultatelor de la Al Jazeera, dupa parerea mea cea mai cunoscuta sursa de informatii din Orientul Mijlociu, pentru lumea vestica. Al doilea lucru este faptul ca nu am vazut articolul de la BBC desi citesc prima pagina a ziarului aproape zilnic.

Ce apare in comun la cele mai multe articole recente este formularea:  "mai multe exporturi" ("boost exports", "more exports", "increased exports", "more concessions","more goods") intarita de: "relaxand si mai mult restrictiile" ("further easing" x4 , "further relaxation"). Ce intelegem de aici este ca exporturile erau limitate dar acum aceasta limitare este mult mai putin stringenta si mai intelegem ca blocada asupra fasiei Gaza a fost relaxata anterior. In ciuda acestei atmosfere optimiste BBC mentioneaza apoi ca "din 2007 practic orice export din Gaza a fost interzis". De ce ai vrea sa scoti in evidenta ca au existat totusi exporturi din Gaza cand acestea au fost practic inexistente?
Trei dintre articole mentioneaza si ca Gaza este condusa de gruparea "militanta" Hamas, lucru adevarat de altfel, nu stiu daca mai important decat distinctia: Gaza are dreptul la zero exporturi din 2007 iar acum are dreptul sa exporte mobila, textile si produse agricole, dar se pare ca nu in Israel (sursa: Yahoo), deci, cel mai probabil, doar in West Bank.
Dupa parerea mea un titlu impartial ar fi fost: "dupa 3 ani de blocada Israelul permite statului Gaza sa exporte mobila, textile si produse agricole in West Bank". Asta e stirea, despre asta e vorba, nu despre Hamas, nu despre statele vestice care saluta cu entuziasm initiativa israeliana.

Doar 3 rezultate din 11 se refera la alte evenimente, la o privire sumara as zice ca 2 sunt anti Israel(7 si 10) si unul pro (11). Nu mai stau sa le descos ca mi-a ajuns.